People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Roast beef sandwich with au jus was excellent. Pasta with shrimp was tasty and bold. Half lettuce wedge salad was the size of an entree. Chicken with pasta was the only thing that did not make the cut. The pasta was a bit salty and the chicken was dry. Overall, a good experience and we will be back. ”
“ Great Food (and tons of it!) at great prices. Grew up coming here and make sure I make it back every time I come home. ”
“ Food was fantastic. Great burger and wings. Very old school type restaurant. Enjoyed it and will go back ”
“ Came with my cousin and niece today. Immediately when I parked and saw the facade, I knew what the vibe would be and when I walked inside I was totally right. This is the neighborhood place where everyone at the bar knows each other and you can tell they come here all the time and I love that. Deb was our waitress and she was wonderful!! The teriyaki potstickers special were so crispy and flavorful! My niece loved her sliders! ”
“ Brick Cafe is amazing food and they have big portions and the staff is very friendly and very helpful and respectful and the restaurant is very clean. ”
“ This place is a 10 out of 10. The ambience is magical, the food is out of this world, and the people/service are great. The burger was a huge hand formed patty, cooked to perfection with just enough charcoal goodness and lots of juciness. The fries were totally crispy and beautifully golden brown. Great little out-of-the-way place! ”
“ We had a reservation, but placed was packed so we had to wait past our reservation time, BUT, both the bartender and Owner/Host -?(Mark) were very attentive while we had to wait. When you sit down @ your table they serve complimentary Chips w/minced Chop meat & onion, absolutely delicious. We ordered a Caesar's salad to split and something about the dressing that made it not right. It was tangy and too creamy, I don't recommend it. For dinner we ordered the Filet Mignon tidbits and Chicken tidbits. The Filet Mignon tidbits were cooked PERFECT, excellent dish. The Chicken tidbits were very good, but once you bite into the Filet Mignon tidbits, you forget about the Chicken tidbits, Ha! Great waitress which is SO IMPORTANT. Not once did we feel rushed being the place was packed and probably wanted our table. We'll be back, probably for Sauerbraten night. ”
“ Wonderful local spot for great food and drinks! My friend and I came for dinner and drinks before seeing a friend play in a band here. The drinks were strong and perfect. There was a bit of a wait for our table and the bar was super crowded but every was so nice and friendly so it was all good! When we did sit down we ordered the pretzel appetizer and it was so good!! The cheese sauce was spicy but the perfect kind of spicy and the mustard sauce tasted like a cross between mustard and ranch and it was great!! For dinner my friend and I split the chicken tidbits sandwich and the French onion soup burger. The chicken sandwich was great, but, the burger was UNBELIEVABLE! It was perfectly cooked, smothered in cheese and the onions were caramelized and full of flavor. Right then and there we made plans to come back again so we could each have our own. I really love this place (reminiscent of one of my other favorite local spots- Corner Galley in Massapequa) and the only reason it's 4 starts instead of 5 is because the service was pretty awful. Now, it was insanely crowded and it looked like they were understaffed so I understand, but every time we needed something we had to flag her down. She never bothered to come check on us. It took a good 30 minutes from getting our appetizer until we were able to get her attention to even just order our dinner. Regardless, we still had a great meal and will be back again for that amazing burger! ”
Menu
Potato Skins
Chicken Bruschetta
Chicken Caesar Salad
Asian Salad
Chicken Caesar Wrap
About
Maier's Brick Cafe
Welcome to Maier's Brick Cafe, a charming seafood and American cuisine spot located at 157 Lakeview Ave in Lynbrook, NY. This beloved neighborhood gem is known for its generous portions, friendly staff, and welcoming ambiance.
As a food reviewer, I had the pleasure of sampling some of Maier's Brick Cafe's standout dishes. The roast beef sandwich with au jus is a must-try, with tender meat and flavorful dipping sauce. The pasta with shrimp is bold and tasty, while the half lettuce wedge salad is a hearty option that can easily double as an entree.
One customer raved about the great prices and ample portions, stating that they make it a point to return whenever they're in town. Another praised the fantastic burgers and wings, highlighting the restaurant's old-school charm.
But what truly sets Maier's Brick Cafe apart is the sense of community and familiarity that greets you as soon as you walk through the door. From the friendly staff to the regulars at the bar, there's a sense of belonging that makes dining here a truly special experience.
Overall, Maier's Brick Cafe is a hidden gem worth discovering. Whether you're looking for a cozy spot for a family meal or a welcoming hangout to catch up with friends, this restaurant checks all the boxes. Don't miss out on the opportunity to experience the delicious food, warm hospitality, and inviting atmosphere that Maier's Brick Cafe has to offer.
Book a table